I was away so Matt has written a really good report:
-------------------------------------------------------------
You were in the Orkney Islands and Ben was directing planes so Steve, Richard and myself ate all the biscuits. First up:
Havana
First play for me and I sneaked in and got loads of points in a single turn, despite a concerted attempt to stop me. It wasn't what I expected at all and it certainly doesn't owe much to Cuba. I was a bit unsure if I liked it or not, so I suggested a rematch:
Matt 23, Richard 12, Steve 7
Closer this time. In an unprecedented move, Steve found himself in what he thought was a knigmaking position in that he could remove a building from play that either Richard or myself could build to win. Steve um'd and ah'd for a while (only a while? - Garry) and decided that he'd enabled Richard to win because I'd won the last game. then Richard sportingly pointed out that he thought that Steve wasn't in a kingmaking position as he could remove the building the Richard has his eye on and the other building that I could build scored only enough points to bring Richard to 19 rather than twenty. The upshot was that Richard talked Steve into removing the building that would have won him the game, then Richard built the building I was going to build and win with then it was my turn.
Richard's build action revealed another building that I had the resources to build- so I built that instead and won. I debated pointing this out to them whilst the ruminating was going on, but the brutal irony of Richard talking Steve out of helping him win was too funny to miss. I don't think I like Havana, there seems to be too much dog-piling the leader and AP about who will do this, so you should do that.
Matt 23, Richard 19, Steve 10
Then we played:
San Juan
I thought this would be closer than it was. Steve had a Harbour/Customs Office combo rolling and both he and Richard had Silver Smelters cooking from about turn 3. Fortunately for me, Steve built a Triumphal Arch without any other monuments which scored me points for Cathedral and didn't do much else. Result!
Matt 43, Richard 32, Steve 26
-------------------------------------------------------------
You were in the Orkney Islands and Ben was directing planes so Steve, Richard and myself ate all the biscuits. First up:
Havana
First play for me and I sneaked in and got loads of points in a single turn, despite a concerted attempt to stop me. It wasn't what I expected at all and it certainly doesn't owe much to Cuba. I was a bit unsure if I liked it or not, so I suggested a rematch:
Matt 23, Richard 12, Steve 7
Closer this time. In an unprecedented move, Steve found himself in what he thought was a knigmaking position in that he could remove a building from play that either Richard or myself could build to win. Steve um'd and ah'd for a while (only a while? - Garry) and decided that he'd enabled Richard to win because I'd won the last game. then Richard sportingly pointed out that he thought that Steve wasn't in a kingmaking position as he could remove the building the Richard has his eye on and the other building that I could build scored only enough points to bring Richard to 19 rather than twenty. The upshot was that Richard talked Steve into removing the building that would have won him the game, then Richard built the building I was going to build and win with then it was my turn.
Richard's build action revealed another building that I had the resources to build- so I built that instead and won. I debated pointing this out to them whilst the ruminating was going on, but the brutal irony of Richard talking Steve out of helping him win was too funny to miss. I don't think I like Havana, there seems to be too much dog-piling the leader and AP about who will do this, so you should do that.
Matt 23, Richard 19, Steve 10
Then we played:
San Juan
I thought this would be closer than it was. Steve had a Harbour/Customs Office combo rolling and both he and Richard had Silver Smelters cooking from about turn 3. Fortunately for me, Steve built a Triumphal Arch without any other monuments which scored me points for Cathedral and didn't do much else. Result!
Matt 43, Richard 32, Steve 26
No comments:
Post a Comment